Why does education have so many Chicken or Egg arguments?

Technology vs Paper and Pen

‘Traditional’ vs ‘Progressive’ pedagogies

Knowledge vs Skills

Quantitative vs Qualitative data

Cross-Curricular/Integrated vs Single Discipline/Subject

I’m not sure why so many of these dichotomous arguments emerge – every one of them to me is a case of both being appropriate depending on the context and circumstance. Any ideas on why these bi-polar arguments erupt continuously in education? Does it happen in other industries as well?

This post is Day 14 of my Question Quest.


3 thoughts on “Why does education have so many Chicken or Egg arguments?

  1. Maybe because it has more chicken and egg people (or maybe more accurately more chicken OR egg people). However, what will save the profession in the end will I believe be the fact that the vast majority are “neither” people.

  2. Interesting question! Perhaps one reason is that too many people see child development and learning as a linear sequential process–One must do this before one can move on to the next level. Unfortunately, this leads to a very narrow view of building blocks, not taking into account the many ways those blocks can be put together, knocked down, and put together again. Until all educators view learning as a both-and, spiraling proposition, I fear the chicken-egg phenomenon will continue to exist.
    PS– And don’t forget whole language-phonics! Ugh!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s